Snuffed Out – AEW WrestleDream Bryan Danielson vs Jon Moxley

This article contains spoilers and results for the end of the AEW WrestleDream 2024 pay per view, along with discussion of simulated violence, real injury, and references material from AEW produced television and secondary programming, outside press interviews, and direct statements from wrestlers involved.

I love a story with a definitive.

I’ve never enjoyed episodic, continuity abandoning productions that span endlessly. A lot of sitcoms and animation fall into this trap, and the appeal of the unending, or the forever, is fresh in the cultural zeitgeist of an ever expanding, ever growing world.

There is one this we as humans will all experience.

The end.

I don’t think death is our only end though, whether one approaches life this way willingly or by force, we are tasked with recognizing when we will end things, when we must stop, when the course must change.

For Bryan Danielson, in Tacoma Washington Saturday night, he chose an end.

Whether you’ve been following Bryan from the beginning of his career on the independents, to his rise in the mainstream or his twilight return under AEW’s infancy, you learned early on just how much love the world of wrestling has for him, and how much he loves it back. His power to capture audiences bested the powers that be at his last employer, and his command of the crowd and people among him was threaded into everything, from the back stage to ring.

Many, many wrestlers have gone on record in various positions to sing their praise for the man. In AEW’s official publications, like their podcast series, the volume of younger wrestlers who cite Bryan as an inspiration is almost cute–when it came time for some of these wrestlers to face Bryan, this respect was palatable, his work with Daniel Garcia, Lee Moriarty, Wheeler Yuta, and others held a decent amount of run time throughout his career. Wrestlers he hasn’t gotten in the ring with on television say just as much, Jade Cargill, now with WWE, discussed wrestling, practicing and studying with Danielson and mentor William Regal in the early hours before the show, just as the ring was built and set.

Certainly wrestlers sung their praises of Danielson outside of AEW proper as well, in the latest press tour for the last several pay per views where Bryan held the belt, Orange Cassidy offered one of the most common refrains people offer in appreciation of the man, “It’s Bryan Danielson!“

By no means has AEW been light on the framing surrounding Bryan’s twilight before and after winning the AEW world title. Using Green Day’s acoustic closing with a flash through of his career, using the Ring of Honor brand to resurface work from Bryan’s independent heyday, tasking his coworkers both young and old to talk about him in the lead up to his match with Swerve.

Renee Paquette has been essential to this front, unsurprisingly. One of the most respected and skilled presenters AEW has, her intertwined inquiry and personal connection allowed for a lot to be constructed with very little, especially in the boil over to the events in Tacoma.

Which, we need to discuss now.

As someone who was invested in both Bryan and Moxley upon their entrance in AEW (and as someone who despised their work together in WWE) the onset of the Blackpool Combat Club set my heart on fire. In reading Moxley’s audio book earlier this year, his philosophical approach to wrestling, at least in my mind, feels akin to the structure of long epics with a commitment to acting on instinct. Bryan brought in patience, he’s a tactician and emotional provocateur all at once. Their dedication to real martial arts and storytelling alike has always been meant to meld, they made it clear that as much as they differ, they came together because they clicked.

What happened at All Out was meant to be from the beginning.

There’s a lot to point fingers at, injuries and plans surely play a role in everything this group has gone through together, even now, but that unescapable reality was something no one in wrestling can account for, at least right away. Early in the sense of conflict, one could easily point the finger at Bryan, going off on dream match after dream match, setting his sights on things alone; the group made it clear that they were wolves, they hunted and could fight their own battles, and singles gold put the group at the top endlessly. The BCC was formed with the belief they could change wrestling, disrupt the future to sculpt such a young, sprouting roster into the future.

The worst part is, they didn’t fail.

I’ll take you now to the match.

Bryan and Moxley have gone after each other time and time again. What has felt heavy in these battles is how fluid it feels, how the violence and movement feels comfortable even with the level of violence and stakes brought to the table.

Moxley has been focusing on a lot in his return. In promos, he addresses the stagnancy. His co-conspariters call out to what to them is the obvious, that diplomacy has failed, that the way to the future is violence. The BCC hasn’t just terrorized Bryan of course, his crew ripped through others with violence, Private Party being one of them.

While this story isn’t about them, in an interview, again with Renee, Moxley’s terror amongst the locker room hasn’t escaped them, they call it out directly, Isiah’s busted hand is proof. He calls on Renee directly that’s her man doing this, terrorizing them, causing harm like that. In that same interview, she asked the tag team if they think Moxley digging into them, attacking their static status and their failures, may be right.

They agree.

In the pre-show, Renee expresses her conflict, how close she is to Bryan’s wife, how many fond moments her, Bryan and Moxley have had. She doesn’t talk about Moxley much, other than this shared fear that tonight something bad will happen.

In an interview with her husband some time ago, the two of them talk about their basement, a gym Mox is building out for the BCC to train in. The two of them seem excited for this future, paired up with people they love.

Bryan and Moxley are mirrors in a way, they intact the same violence because they planned the same violence, the mutualism between their move sets are bound in just as much blood as they are training hours. Their flourishes to the crowd command them forward. They know exactly how to inflict pain to each other’s bodies.

What stands out with this feud, despite the serendipity is how clinical it all feels, almost impersonal with the way Moxley collectivizes his actions. Bringing in Marina, Pac and Claudio not only works for him on the level of connection, but in mutual frustration. Both Claudio and Pac had faced Bryan at moments they could have won gold, and his command over the crowd and his patience in all of what comes right to him leaves a searing in their guts that was clearer even before Moxley’s intentions were clearly known. Moxley allows these three to intact violence and disruption, Marina especially is entrusted in this role during the match and using her to play dirty keeps everyone off their game, largely because they are used to Moxley enacting violence of his own accord. Moxley refuses to relent, he presses on the gas though at the same time he makes it clear this is bigger than him or Bryan or the belt itself, and what is compelling this is much, much bigger.

Moxley is a man concerned with future.

Bryan, and us, lived in every moment he had.

When it comes down to the match itself, there shouldn’t have been a question that Danielson was on a time limit. He was clear with the audience again and again that he would need neck surgery soon. He won the belt. He was our champion, and no one wanted this to end.

Moxley was the stronger man, the man who could withhold more ache.

The future was not a celebration, it was not grandiose.

Jon Moxley welcomed us to the future with silence, and gasping for air, with the slumped body of our hero, with his gold shoved into an undescriptive bag. In an instant, the title went away, wrestling went away, and he dug for something deeper.

Something has to change.

What happens in the ring next irrupts into horror, into sobbing, into violence. Brutalization is the goal, not resolution. With every stomp and slam you are left to watch Bryan suffer. If the cloud of retirement dominated the build, Bryan’s survival dominated the fall. Even out of desperation you watch one of the last people who stood by Bryan try, until he’s captured by the grief of it all.

Until it’s clear that Moxley’s words have. dug. deeper.

The slam of the bag on Yuta’s chest, the moment you realize what’s coming.

Of what haunts me most, before Excalibur on commentary cracks into tears, is Wheeler Yuta, the man they chose for the future screaming at Bryan to stop moving as he suffocates him.

An ending, if there can ever be a true end.

Through everything assembled and enacted in Washington last night, what haunts everyone from the faces of those who ran out to protect him, to the cagey haunted demeanor of everyone in the company, to the sense of surreal emptiness I felt when it ended, what’s clear to me is despite the intricacies and faults of the medium, Bryan Danielson and Jon Moxley set out to construct a home in AEW with doors they opened, and now Bryan has closed.

I am desperate for the next open door.

If this is an ending, I am desperate to know what the future looks like with Bryan’s light being snuffed out.

I need to see what wrestlers start burning bright in his wake.

About Webmistress Ave

I’m Avery, the one who primarily develops this site. I’m 22, mixed Mexican/Hispano, a student, a butch lesbian—I can keep listing things. I use any pronouns, not in singularity. Do not use a singular set for “simplicity.”
This entry was posted in Reviews, Writing and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply